top of page

Catering Menu

 Sandwich Trays


5 super sub platters 30 4” pieces Serves 20-30   112.00


3 Super sub platters 18 4” pieces Serves 12-18.  68.00


Choose (3 or 5) from the following:


Italian - Classic Italian with provolone, ham capicola, salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & oregano and our special pepper relish.


Turkey - Deli Turkey with provolone lettuce and tomato.


Tuna Salad - Generous scoops of homemade tuna salad with lettuce and tomato.


Chicken Salad - Generous scoops of homemade chicken salad with lettuce and tomato.


Ham - Deli Ham with provolone lettuce and tomato.


Veggie - Sautéed mushrooms, onions and peppers with sauteed spinach & garlic, provolone, lettuce, raw onion, tomato, oregano and our house tomato vinaigrette. (V)


Ask us to create your own custom sub platter

Cold Cuts Platter

Basic cold cuts - Ham, Capicola, Genoa Salami,

Turkey, Corned Beef, Provolone, American & Swiss cheeses.

Comes with pickles and choice of potato salad or coke slaw.

Medium (serves 12-15) 49.00

Large (serves 25-30)  95.00

Condiments & Sides


Side salad

(Choice of Ranch, Italian, Balsamic or Bleu Cheese)

Large 9.99

Small 4.99

Potato Salad

8 oz - 3.75

16 oz - 7.50

32 oz - 15.00


Cole Slaw

8 oz - 3.75

16 oz - 7.50

32 oz - 15.00


Condiment Tray

Lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles

and choice of pepper relish, sweet pepper mayo

or spicy pepper mayo




Brioche buns

Eight pack - 5.00


Sliders buns

Twelve pack - 5.00


6” Hoagie rolls

Ten pack - 9.00


Italian loaf

sliced - 6.00


Marble Rye loaf

sliced - 7.00




Three Kinds of meatballs in our homemade sauce

sprinkled with pecorino Romano cheese.


Antoinette's Italian - A classic Italian beef meatball.

Lisa’s Calabrese - A special spicy beef and sausage meatball.

Stuffed Pepper Meatball - A beef and sausage meatball

                                                        with peppers and onions baked in


Half Dozen 14.00

Dozen 27.00

Crab cake


Homemade Crab cakes with a breaded parmesan crust.


Half Dozen 60.00

Dozen 120.00

Dessert Trays

Party Sample Box

Individual portions of Triple Chocolate Cake, Strawberry Shortcake, 

Peanut Butter Brownie, Blondie, Éclair and  Tiramisu.



Cannoli Platter

​30 mini cannoli's of assorted flavors. (Plain, Chocolate, Strawberry, 

Blueberry, Cherry, Chocolate Cherry and Ginger Bread)



Large Assorted Platter

30 pieces of Chocolate Chip Cookie, Assorted flavor Cannoli

& Iced Brownies.



Individual desserts available

Assorted Cannoli (Plain, Chocolate, Strawberry, 

Blueberry, Cherry, Chocolate Cherry and Ginger Bread)

Strawberry Shortcake, Triple Chocolate Cake, Peanut Butter Brownie,

Iced Brownie, Blondie, Burnt Almond Torte, Tiramisu,

Éclair, and Bread Pudding.



Soda Cans  (12oz) ​1.00

​Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Diet Sprite, Root Beer

Soda & Tea  (20oz) 2.75

​Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Root Beer, Sweet Tea, Diet Tea, Unsweet Tea

Water (16oz) ​1.50

2 liter soda 3.50

​Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Diet Sprite, Root Beer



Choose from any of our homemade sauces and dressings including: spicy pepper relish, sweet pepper mayo, spicy pepper mayo, hollandaise, house dressing, tomato vinaigrette, thousand island, tartar, or dijonnaise. 8oz container.    3.00

  • Orders must be placed 48 hours in advance or by December 20th for December 24th pickup

  • Prepay required on orders over $100.00

  • Place orders in person, over the phone, through email, or in person at both locations

  • We accept cash or card

Thank you for choosing New York Super Subs & Bakery!

Italian Profile.jpg
Veggie Sub closeup.JPG
Crabcake Portion.jpg
bottom of page